Best Running Shoes Compared: ON, Nike, Asics & More

If you’ve ever shopped for running shoes, you know it can get pretty overwhelming. There are so many brands—ON, New Balance, Nike, Puma, Asics—and each one claims to have the “best” shoe. So how do you pick?

Well, the truth is, the “best” running shoe is really the one that fits your feet, your running style, and your goals. To help you out, I’ve broken down the basics about these popular brands, what they’re known for, and who they’re really best suited for. Think of this as your no-nonsense guide to making a solid choice without getting lost in marketing buzz.


Why Your Running Shoes Matter More Than You Think

Running in the wrong shoes isn’t just uncomfortable — it can lead to blisters, aches, or even injuries like shin splints or plantar fasciitis. The right shoes absorb shock, support your feet, and help you run better.

So yeah, picking the right pair is worth some thought!


ON Running Shoes: The Swiss Tech That Feels Like Clouds

ON is kind of the cool new kid on the block with its unique “CloudTec” cushioning. Imagine little pods on the sole that squish when you land and snap back when you push off. It’s like running on clouds but with a spring in your step.

If you like lightweight shoes that don’t weigh you down, and you love a sleek look, ON could be your jam. Just keep in mind some folks find those pods a bit odd on rough trails.

Technology

  • CloudTec Cushioning: Individual pods (“clouds”) on the sole compress upon landing and lock firm on push-off, offering a blend of softness and propulsion.
  • Speedboard: A plate inside the sole that supports foot roll and gives a springy feel.
  • Lightweight Design: Many models are feather-light, making them popular for race days.

Ideal For

  • Runners who want lightweight shoes with responsive cushioning.
  • Those who enjoy a natural foot motion.
  • People looking for stylish, versatile shoes that transition well from running to casual wear.

Pros

  • Unique cushioning feels different from traditional foam.
  • Stylish and modern aesthetics.
  • Good for road running and some trails.

Cons

  • Some find the CloudTec pods uncomfortable on uneven terrain.
  • Higher price point compared to some competitors.

New Balance: The Comfort and Fit Expert

If you want shoes that feel like they were made just for your feet, New Balance is where you should look. They offer a ton of sizes and widths, so no matter if you have wide or narrow feet, they’ve got you covered.

Their Fresh Foam cushioning feels plush but supportive—perfect for long runs or those days when you want something comfy. They’re not always the flashiest, but they get the job done.

Technology

  • Fresh Foam: Cushioned midsole foam designed for a plush, supportive ride.
  • FuelCell: A springy foam for more energy return and faster runs.
  • Stability Features: Many models offer medial posts or dual-density foam for overpronators.

Ideal For

  • Runners needing extra stability or wide fit options.
  • Those who value comfort and cushioning for long runs.
  • People who want reliable, durable shoes for daily training.

Pros

  • Extensive size and width options.
  • Balanced cushioning and support.
  • Durable outsole materials.

Cons

  • Design may feel less flashy compared to newer brands.
  • Some models are heavier than competitors.

Nike: Innovation Meets Style and Speed

Nike is everywhere, and for good reason. Their shoes often use the latest tech like Air Zoom or React foam to give you a snappy, energetic feel. If you’re chasing speed or want a shoe that looks as good as it performs, Nike’s got plenty of options.

Heads up: some models run a bit narrow, so try them on before you buy.

Technology

  • Nike Air Zoom: Pressurized air units providing responsive cushioning.
  • React Foam: Lightweight foam offering a balance of cushioning and energy return.
  • Vaporfly Series: Carbon fiber plates for marathon and racing performance.

Ideal For

  • Speed-focused runners and racers.
  • People who want a blend of style and cutting-edge tech.
  • Those who appreciate a snug, performance-oriented fit.

Pros

  • Advanced technologies for speed and responsiveness.
  • Wide range of models for all distances.
  • Strong brand reputation and availability.

Cons

  • Some models can be expensive.
  • Narrower fits may not suit all foot types.

Puma: Affordable, Lightweight, and Stylish

Puma’s been stepping up their running shoe game with lightweight designs and fresh looks that work for running or casual wear. Their cushioning tech isn’t as advanced as some others, but they offer good bang for your buck.

If you want a budget-friendly shoe that looks great and feels decent on your feet, check out Puma.

Technology

  • NITRO Foam: A cushioning foam aimed at energy return and comfort.
  • ProFoam: Lightweight EVA foam for durability and cushioning.
  • PWRRUN: Responsive midsole foam found in many models.

Ideal For

  • Budget-conscious runners who want style and performance.
  • Casual runners and gym-goers.
  • Those seeking lightweight and flexible shoes.

Pros

  • Affordable price points.
  • Attractive designs that double as casual wear.
  • Lightweight and flexible models.

Cons

  • Less advanced tech compared to top-tier brands.
  • Limited variety for serious runners.

Asics: The Go-To for Support and Stability

If you’ve ever heard that Asics are the go-to for runners who need extra support, it’s true. Their famous GEL cushioning system absorbs shock like a champ, and many models include features to help with overpronation (when your foot rolls inward too much).

They’re built tough and great for runners logging serious miles or those who want a comfy, stable shoe.

Technology

  • GEL Cushioning: Gel pads absorb shock in the heel and forefoot.
  • FlyteFoam: Lightweight midsole foam for comfort and bounce.
  • Dynamic Duomax: Support system for overpronators.

Ideal For

  • Runners who need extra support or have pronation issues.
  • Long-distance runners seeking durability.
  • People who prioritize comfort over flashy design.

Pros

  • Exceptional stability and cushioning.
  • Durable construction ideal for daily miles.
  • Wide selection of sizes and widths.

Cons

  • Designs tend to be bulkier and less trendy.
  • Can be heavier compared to competitors.

How to Pick Your Perfect Running Shoe

  1. Know Your Foot Type: Do you have flat feet? High arches? Overpronate or underpronate? Getting this right helps you choose a shoe that won’t cause problems.
  2. Consider Your Running Style: Training daily? Racing? Trail running? Different shoes fit different needs.
  3. Try Before You Buy: Always test shoes on a treadmill or take a quick run if possible. Comfort is king.
  4. Budget Matters: Some brands run pricey; others offer solid options at lower prices.

The Bottom Line: There’s No One Best Shoe — Just the Best Shoe for You

Each brand shines in its own way. ON is innovative and stylish, New Balance nails comfort and fit, Nike leads in tech and style, Puma offers budget-friendly coolness, and Asics is all about support and durability.

The best shoe is the one that feels good on your feet and keeps you moving without pain.